Skip to content
ApoteichisisOrthodox sources & church history
428 to 431Documented

Nestorius and the Third Ecumenical Council

Νεστόριος

A test case for how the Church treats a reigning bishop who teaches error: he held real office until a council deposed him.

Established chronology

  1. 428Nestorius becomes archbishop of Constantinople.
  2. 429 to 430Controversy over the title Theotokos; St Cyril of Alexandria writes against him.
  3. 431The Third Ecumenical Council at Ephesus condemns and deposes Nestorius.

Synodal decisions

  • Ephesus deposed Nestorius and affirmed Theotokos and the single subject of the incarnate Word.

Actions of the saints

  • St Cyril led the doctrinal opposition; the council addressed Nestorius as a bishop up to the moment of his synodical deposition.

Competing interpretations

  • Some read the case as showing that a heretic's acts are void from the moment of his error; others, that he remained a true bishop until the council deposed him, the reading this library follows and which the conciliar acts support.

Bibliography

  • ACO tom. 1 (Acts of Ephesus).
  • J. McGuckin, St Cyril of Alexandria and the Christological Controversy.